Head-to-head · Comparison
Features, pricing, health score, community ratings — side-by-side from the live MadeOnSol database.
Updated August 11, 2026
 |  | |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | (4) | (8) |
| Pricing | Freemium | Free |
| Health | Healthy | Healthy |
| Chain | multi chain | multi chain |
| Open Source | ||
| Features | 5 features | 8 features |
| Upvotes |
Pros & cons
Analysis
Koinly Koinly is a crypto tax reporting and portfolio management platform that supports Solana wallet imports, SPL token tracking, and DeFi activity categorization. It automatically calculates capital gains,... Phantom Phantom is the most widely used wallet in the Solana ecosystem and has become synonymous with Solana itself. With millions of active users, Phantom provides a seamless gateway to DeFi, NFTs, token swa...
Phantom is rated higher by the MadeOnSol community with 4.6/5 stars across 8 reviews, compared to 4.5/5 for Koinly (4 reviews). That said, ratings only tell part of the story — what matters most is which tool fits your specific workflow.
Koinly uses a freemium model, while Phantom is free — Free to use. Built-in swap charges approximately 0.85% fee. Staking is free with standard validator commission.. Phantom has the edge for budget-conscious users, though Koinly's paid tier may offer features worth paying for.
Koinly offers 5 features including Automatic Solana wallet import and transaction categorization, Capital gains/loss calculation for SOL and SPL tokens, DeFi, staking, and airdrop income tracking, and 2 more. Phantom counters with 8 features including Browser extension and mobile app with full feature parity, Built-in token swap aggregator powered by Jupiter for best prices, Native SOL staking with validator selection and rewards tracking, and 5 more. The right choice depends on which specific features matter for your use case — check the individual review pages for full breakdowns.
We monitor both tools around the clock for uptime, SSL validity, and response times. Koinly currently has a healthy health status with 100.0% uptime over the last 30 days. Phantom is rated healthy with 100.0% uptime. For any tool you trust with your funds, trades, or yield, uptime and speed are non-negotiable.
Koinly's key strengths include most comprehensive solana defi tax coverage available, automatic transaction matching reduces manual work, multi-country tax report generation from one platform.
More comparisons
Compare Koinly with…
Compare Phantom with…
Explore more
Keep comparing
DEXs, RPC providers, liquid-staking protocols, and trading-bot fees — all compared the same way.
| ▲ 2 |
| ▲ 6 |
| Twitter Followers | 5,809 | 949,705 |
| Categories | Portfolio Trackers, Analytics & Charts | Wallets |
| Description | Crypto tax calculator and portfolio tracker with full Solana support | Most-used Solana wallet — send, swap, stake SOL, and manage NFTs with built-in DEX aggregation and hardware wallet support |
While Koinly (Portfolio Trackers) and Phantom (Wallets) serve different primary purposes, users often consider both when building their Solana toolkit. Phantom has the community's vote, but your mileage may vary depending on your specific needs. We recommend trying both — Koinly is free to start and Phantom is free to start. Read user reviews on each tool's page for real-world feedback from the Solana community.